Mafia: The Old Country proves that shorter games at a fair price still work in 2025.

Mark Avatar 2026
By
Mark Tomson
Managing Director of PlayFront. Mark Tomson shapes the vision of independent PlayStation reporting. His focus: technical analysis, hardware evolution, and the strategic positioning of the gaming industry. He stands for...
2 MinRead

Despite mediocre reviews, Mafia: The Old Country has reached the top of the PS Store charts. Why the old formula of fair playtime and price still works today.

Surprise in the PlayStation Store: Mafia: The Old Country It topped the European PS5 charts in August and even managed to reach third place in North America. What's remarkable is that the title wasn't a critical darling, but rather described by many reviews as "Solid, but unspectacular“ was classified.

Nevertheless, the game has reached the masses, apparently with a strategy rarely seen in recent years: a manageable playtime and an affordable entry price. In times when many blockbusters cost 70 euros and offer 60 hours of gameplay, this strategy seems to have struck a chord.

PlayStation Store Charts August

Besides Mafia: The Old Country The hardcore shooter phenomenon has also emerged. Ready or Not (our review) again strongly maintained its position – 3rd place in Europe and 2nd place in North America. There, it secured Madden NFL 26 the top spot, while the sports game doesn't even appear in the top 20 in Europe.

Also new in the charts: Gears of War: Reloaded (NA: 4th place, EU: 7th place) and Metal Gear Solid D: Snake Eater (NA: Rank 7, EU: Rank 6). As always, classics like GTA V or Minecraft are still regular guests.

What Mafia: The Old Country shows us

That Mafia: The Old Country The fact that a game lands so high in the charts despite not offering a gameplay revolution is a signal. Players don't always want the biggest open-world behemoth or the most expensive AAA production. Sometimes a tightly structured story-driven game with a clear length and a fair price is enough to achieve success.

Whether this is a lasting trend or just an isolated case remains to be seen. But it could be a sign for developers. Not every game has to be gigantic to sell well.

Mafia: The Old Country It's not a perfect game, but it has shown that the classic formula for success – short, snappy, affordable – still works today. Perhaps that's exactly the kind of variety many players have been looking for.

How do you think?

GTA Pre-Order Release
Share This Article

Community Talk

Subscribe
Notify me
5 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Chanjo
9. September 2025 07: 42

The Old Country is no better than part 3. And that one was already crap. I didn't finish Old Country.

Crydog
8. September 2025 19: 43

Why do you always think short games are better than long ones? It depends on the passing and how the open world or linear levels are used. With Mafia, for example, the way the world was used, they should have just made it a linear level from the start.

Frank Müller
8. September 2025 07: 54

Yes, I love it. If games are too long, I lose interest so quickly. Linear, short, and with a great, woke-free story = the best!!

X8BL
8. September 2025 11: 03

It wasn't that short at all. The PlayStation says 20 hours. Perfectly normal, I think, and the price was fair.

Embryo weighing hundreds of pounds
8. September 2025 10: 27

I can also enjoy shorter games at full price, because a long playtime doesn't necessarily make a game good. 10-20 hours is ideal for me.

The Trends

PS5 / PS5 Pro – New firmware beta unlocks PSSR 2 improvement

The new PS5 beta update brings automatic activation for the PS5 Pro…

Ghost Recon Wildlands: Free 4K/60 fps upgrade and final story mission available

Ghost Recon Wildlands receives a free upgrade after 9 years: 4K/60FPS for PS5,…

GTA 6: Pre-orders are underway, but preview reports are completely missing.

GTA 6 will be released in November 2026, and pre-orders are open. However, there are no hands-on reviews at all.