Sony put up a strong fight after the former Bungie-head Chris Barrett has filed a lawsuit worth 200 million dollars against the company. The lawsuit, which was filed shortly before Christmas 2024, accuses Sony of treating Barrett unfairly after his 25-year career at the studio. However, those responsible at Sony did not simply let this go. They did not hesitate for long and did not miss the opportunity to finally counter. At the same time, piquant details were revealed about what goes on in management.
Intimate details on 128 pages
The response came promptly in the form of a 128-page statement of claim intended to refute Barrett's allegations once and for all - or at least vehemently deny them. As part of this response, Sony published text messages intended to expose Barrett's behavior from their point of view. According to Sony, Barrett's alleged misconduct was the real reason for his dismissal, not the takeover by Sony. In the published messages, there are statements that show Barrett in a very questionable light, which he allegedly communicated to the "victims" of his messages. Some text messages read something like this: "I'm just worried. I really like texting you and talking to you. I don't want him to get the right idea [wrong idea?]." […] "I hope [your boyfriend] doesn't mind me texting you so much".
This news raises questions, especially when viewed in the context of the indictment, which Barrett's lawyers portray as "manipulation" and "dishonesty" by Sony. The debate unfolding here is a real drama - and not just legal. To outsiders, it almost feels like a gaming industry thriller, with much more at stake than just contractual issues and financial compensation.
Things are relaxed at the top
But it's not just the fight over the money that is the drama. The text messages that got Barrett into trouble could spark a wider discussion about the behavior of executives in the gaming industry. The last scandal of this kind involved former Activision CEO Bobby Kotick, who was accused ofto encourage such behavior.
Sony is not only struggling with the financial pressure, but also with the salacious details that have come to light as a result of this lawsuit. While Barrett's lawyers doubt the seriousness of Sony's allegations, the company has done everything it can to sway public opinion in its favor.
The legal battle is likely to continue in the coming months - and who knows what other details will come to light. The gaming world will not miss out on this exchange of blows, and the consequences could go far beyond this one lawsuit.
[Update] Through counsel and Council representation, Mr. Barret released the following statement today:
"Sony continues to disingenuously cherry-pick text messages and alleged conversations and make unsubstantiated and conclusory statements to defame Christopher and justify his termination in order to avoid paying him what he is owed under his employment agreements. Significantly, Sony is not attaching the full text messages or the entire contents of these conversations as evidence, and nothing in Sony's response provides a legitimate legal or factual basis for terminating Christopher for cause. Christopher is confident that when all the evidence is presented, it will be clear that Sony was engaged in a conspiracy to deprive him of his role and the stock bonuses he has earned for his 25 years of loyal service to the company."
The case is therefore likely to drag on for a while, and the judges will probably have to decide who is right in the end.
English 
German